Here's the thing that I'm sure many of us forget about May, when he did play early in career he was actually productive. Then he got hurt. Then he got fat. Then he couldn't get on the floor. I always wondered if May had not gotten hurt if his situation would have turned out better.
Ammo does get an honorable mention, but I remember clearly and episode of PTI his rookie season when they talked about his 26 point performance. Kornheiser was a believer and said he was going to be "the next larry bird" (LOL) while Wilbon didn't think too much of him. That 26 point performance was nice yes, but then somebody probably told him he sucked at shooting and he took it REAL personal.