Rank each player's value from 1-12

[dnbman]

Make a list of 1 to 12, with one being the highest. Rank the players based on value to the team. Feel free to explain your decision process along the way. Keep in mind, you may value a player highly because of trade value if you like.

13-15 will be "Those not worth ranking." Sorry for the confusion.

[The Prodigy]

Which 3 players are we not including on the list?

[dnbman]

Which 3 players are we not including on the list?

13-15 will be "Those not worth ranking." Sorry for the confusion.

[SWedd523]

Trade value and team value are different things in my book so I'd have separate lists. I'll look at the roster in a few and put my values up

[BlockParty]

Make a list of 1 to 12, with one being the highest. Rank the players based on value to the team. Feel free to explain your decision process along the way. Keep in mind, you may value a player highly because of trade value if you like.

13-15 will be "Those not worth ranking." Sorry for the confusion.

zsalaries.JPG

If you can't read the picture, it's this link: http://hoopshype.com/salaries/charlotte.htm

I have to take what we pay them into consideration because a new bentley for $20k is more valuable than a new honda for $20k, which should push the players on their rookie contracts higher, given the same or similar production.

1. DJ Paid $2.5M but one of our top 4 players in most games
2. Diaw He is able to guard most people at 3 different positions, and has shown flexibility to adapt to most situations (this is also the reason the TTime probably hasn't seen more playing time, and Boris hasn't be traded~he's that valuable to us).
3. GW Probably most valuable trading piece, also the 'face' of our team from the fans perspective
4. Jackson-less trade value than DJ, Boris or GW
5. Nazr-expiring contract is big plus, and he's our only big with back-to-the basket moves
6. TTime-needs more minutes to justify the contract (or justify him being over paid)
7. McGuire-Hustle galore at a low price, but needs some coaching to realize he's not a jump shooter
8. UPS-He needs to show the ability to consistent make a 15 ft jumper ala Udonis Haslem
9. Kwame-takes up an amazing amount of space, and cheap in relative terms, put a fish out of water in this offense
10. Hendo-Huge upside because of rookie contract, but Jack has to be traded for a Big for it to be realized
11. Livingston $3.5M paid and I'm just waiting for the knee to crumble (though I love the potential)
12. Matt Carroll His production may increase if he continues to see minutes (in the new offense scoring helps)


13-15 Najera, Diop and Collins-production versus amount paid does not make sense (and the potential doesn't seem to change, even with Diop's blocks or rebounding ability).

[K1NGofAKR0N]

1. dj
2 wallace
3. Jax
4. Tyrus
5. boris
6. nazr
7. ups
8 livingston
9. henderson
10. dominic
11 matt carroll
12. kwame

[dnbman]

Trade value and team value are different things in my book so I'd have separate lists. I'll look at the roster in a few and put my values up

I see your point, but I'm thinking more of an overall value, considering both. Feel free to do it however you like though!

[Chef]

Attachment 372

If you can't read the picture, it's this link: http://hoopshype.com/salaries/charlotte.htm

I have to take what we pay them into consideration because a new bentley for $20k is more valuable than a new honda for $20k, which should push the players on their rookie contracts higher, given the same or similar production.

1. DJ Paid $2.5M but one of our top 4 players in most games
2. Diaw He is able to guard most people at 3 different positions, and has shown flexibility to adapt to most situations (this is also the reason the TTime probably hasn't seen more playing time, and Boris hasn't be traded~he's that valuable to us).
3. GW Probably most valuable trading piece, also the 'face' of our team from the fans perspective
4. Jackson-less trade value than DJ, Boris or GW
5. Nazr-expiring contract is big plus, and he's our only big with back-to-the basket moves
6. TTime-needs more minutes to justify the contract (or justify him being over paid)
7. McGuire-Hustle galore at a low price, but needs some coaching to realize he's not a jump shooter
8. UPS-He needs to show the ability to consistent make a 15 ft jumper ala Udonis Haslem
9. Kwame-takes up an amazing amount of space, and cheap in relative terms, put a fish out of water in this offense
10. Hendo-Huge upside because of rookie contract, but Jack has to be traded for a Big for it to be realized
11. Livingston $3.5M paid and I'm just waiting for the knee to crumble (though I love the potential)
12. Matt Carroll His production may increase if he continues to see minutes (in the new offense scoring helps)


13-15 Najera, Diop and Collins-production versus amount paid does not make sense (and the potential doesn't seem to change, even with Diop's blocks or rebounding ability).

this seems about right to me. i would switch livingston with kwame. if mcguire can make a 15 footer at 40% he would move up to nazr's level

[teej]

I'm going to do this as if I was an opposing GM looking to trade for them. And I'm going in reverse order:

13-15: Carroll, Diop, Sherron
12: Najera
11: Henderson
10: Kwame
9: McGuire
8: UPS
7: Liv
6: Crash
5: Diaw
4: Jack
3: Nazr
2: Tyrus
1: DJ

[Chef]

I'm going to do this as if I was an opposing GM looking to trade for them. And I'm going in reverse order:

13-15: Carroll, Diop, Sherron
12: Najera
11: Henderson
10: Kwame
9: McGuire
8: UPS
7: Liv
6: Crash
5: Diaw
4: Jack
3: Nazr
2: Tyrus
1: DJ

obviously based on my trade thread posts, i would move tyrus way back. i would move it to:
dj, naz, crash, jax, diaw, tyrus...