i was actually a fan of Matt Devlin. thought he was pretty solid. he never had a decent broadcast partner, and i think it drug him down.
on the flip side, he wasnt a homer. if you have a home broadcast team, i think they need to kind of root for their team. Devlin and especially Adrian Branch almost seemed to not care if they won or lost and adrian spent the whole game telling the fans how bad the team was... and they wonder why no one watches.
Steve Martin should get the nod. he is absolutely fan freakin tastic as a broadcaster.