Delhomme or Carr

[ziggy]

After watching last night's game I would imagine that the support that Jake has is likely shrinking.

What are your thoughts?

[dvdbumpus]

Jake is overrated due to his upbringing of the team to a super bowl a few years back.

Let Carr have a try, he has a higher ceiling and the defense will help him out dramatically.

[ALong13]

I'm not a Panthers fan, but if I was, I'd totally want Carr as QB. Delhomme is a fake, he's never been good, and never will be a top QB, if he didn't have the recievers he had, he would have never had any good years, Carr wasn't in a terrible postion in Houston, and him in Charlotte could help both organizations for the best...but considering I'm a Bucs fan, I hope they keep Delhomme as their QB...

[123together]

CARR NO QUESTIONS ASKED

[WarioVsMooChicken]

BRING BACK WEINKE!

:P

[ziggy]

CARR NO QUESTIONS ASKED

AMEN...I think its only a matter of time before Jake winds up carrying a clipboard.

[qchoops]

When I first saw this post, I was getting ready to rush to Jake's defense. But then I looked at their numbers for last season. Jake did have the better qb rating, but by less than a point, and that playing for a team that did a much better job of protecting the qb (and one with more weapons at his disposal). So, I'm going to have to go with a solid "I don't know", so far. If I had to pick, I'd say Carr, but that's almost as much based on hope than analysis. Delhomme is more of a known commodity to us and Carr is not: The unknown is always tempting.

[Jonathanmartin7]

Jake is the man, they are equal as far as talent goes but Carr is not a leader. Jake is THE leader. I'm glad we got Carr and I think he will eventually be the starter for the Panthers, but he'll need a while to grasp everything. Jakes numbers last year don't show how good he is. at least 5 picks by him were the WR's fault. He also hasn't had a running came to work with. Neither will be worth a damn if Foster/Williams don't bring it this year. We had way, way too many 3rd and longs last year. The offense is designed to be run first. When we only average 2 yards a run(that's a guess) and are stuck in 3rd and 7 all the time it won't matter who is at QB Peyton Manning wouldn't be worth a damn having to do that all the time. So for his leadership I will go with Jake.

[Alex]

Jake is the man and everything but he's WAY to "stupid decisions prone"

Carr is more athletic, more accurate, better arm and has outplayed Jake this pre-season (although he has played against 2nd stringers).

I GUARANTEE that at some point this season Jake will get benched and Carr will take the starting job for good.

[Dead_Real]

I would have to see how Carr would play with the starters for me to make decision between the two. Jake played bad without a doubt but he wasn't the only one our offensive line didn't help him at all pressure was in his face all night I wouldn't go into "bench Jake" mode just yet if he plays the same the next few games and our o line is holding up I'll start to worry.