Given that this yr is basically lost, I would much prefer Dudley to Carroll. I do understand the reasoning you mention, but it is too late to bother with thatthis yr and we might as well get Dudley the minutes. He brings a fire, hustle and grit to the team which we desperately need. I dont want to extinguish that flame. I believe overall that Dudley brings both offense, defense and rebounding to our game whereas Carroll is all about having a 3 pt shooter on the floor for offense. Dudley is much more valuable.