Who is better? Honestly, statistically Gerald is. I havent watched enough of Smith to know really how he plays. He is athletic and I know he has a bit of a mid range, but do his two inches really make him a better solution at PF? He definitely had more of a presence on defense with nearly 3 bpg. Gerald is a great value with his contract, but in my game plan/I want JR thread I think this team can be more successful without him, is Josh Smith worth it? Would he help push this franchise over the edge?