The "All Around" Player

[spectre]

First, I admit I blatantly stole this idea off of the Bucks' board on RGM.

Anyway, rank the players on the 6 different aspects listed 1 thru 10 (10 being highest) based off YOUR perception of the players. You can look at stats o'course, but this is more about how fans think.

I used 5 as around average.

Also, this is obviously not an exact science...so hopefully no one gets offended about anyone else's opinion.


Okafor

Scoring talent - 6
Passing - 5
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 9
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 9

Total - 42/60


Diaw

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 10
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 7
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 5
Total - 41/60


Crash

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 8
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 8

Total 43/60


Bell

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 7
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 9
Help defense - 5

Total 39/60


Felton

Scoring talent - 6
Passing - 8
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 6

Total 40/60


Augustin

Scoring talent - 9
Passing - 7
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 5
Help defense - 6

Total 39/60


Radmanovich

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 5
Help defense - 4

Total 31/60


Diop

Scoring talent - 4
Passing - 5
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 7
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 6

Total 34/60


Howard

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 6

Total 36/60

[Slam]

I like it!! No wonder it came from the Bucks board. If I had Dicky on my roster I'd be looking for distractions too!!

Okafor

Scoring talent - 3
Passing - 3
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 10
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 9

Total - 38/60


Diaw

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 10
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 8
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 5
Help defense - 5
Total - 42/60


Crash

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 8
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 9

Total 43/60


Bell

Scoring talent - 6
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 4
Man defense - 9
Help defense - 5

Total 36/60


Felton

Scoring talent - 5
Passing - 8
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 7
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 6

Total 39/60


Augustin

Scoring talent - 9
Passing - 7
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 7
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 5
Help defense - 5

Total 38/60


Radmanovich

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 5
Help defense - 4

Total 31/60


Diop

Scoring talent - 3
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 7
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 5

Total 31/60


Howard

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 6

Total 36/60

[teej]

Okafor

Scoring talent - 6.5
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 9
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 9

Total - 41.5/60


Diaw

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 10
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 8
Rebounding - 4
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 4
Total - 40/60


Crash

Scoring talent - 8.5
Passing - 5
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 7
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 7.5
Total 43/60


Bell

Scoring talent - 6
Passing - 7
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 8
Rebounding - 3.5
Man defense - 9
Help defense - 6

Total 39.5/60


Felton

Scoring talent - 7.5
Passing - 9
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 7
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 4.5

Total 40/60


Augustin

Scoring talent - 9
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 4
Rebounding - 4
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 6

Total 35/60


Radmanovich

Scoring talent - 8.5
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 4.5
Help defense - 3

Total 30/60


Diop

Scoring talent - 1.5
Passing - 2
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 9
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 7.5
Total 34/60


Howard

Scoring talent - 6.5
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 4
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 5
Total 32.5/60

Nazzy

Scoring Talent - 6
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles - 4
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 5.5
Help Defense - 4
Total 29.5/60

Cartier

Scoring Talent - 7
Passing - 5
Offensive Intangibles - 4.5
Rebounding - 6
Man Defense - 6
Help defense - 4
Total 32.5/60

Lil' Sean

Scoring Talent - 5.5
Passing - 3.5
Offensive Intangibles - 2
Rebounding - 2
Man Defense - 5
Help defense - 2
Total 20/60

[Ghost Kat]

Why is Crash scoring so low on help defense

[teej]

Why is Crash scoring so low on help defense

he's not??

[Ghost Kat]

he's not??

Not to high jack the thread, But in the three that have been posted he's averaging round 7.5 or 8. Crash is probably the best help defender on the team besides Okafor. Most of Wallaces blocks and steals come from help defense.

[bing!]

Someone should add all these up and calculate the average values, after several others have posted their assessments, of course. Maybe even create a wiki article, with some neat tables and such.

I'd post my own rankings had I seen more than tidbits of their playing skill.

[teej]

Not to high jack the thread, But in the three that have been posted he's averaging round 7.5 or 8. Crash is probably the best help defender on the team besides Okafor. Most of Wallaces blocks and steals come from help defense.

9, 8, 7.5

I put 7.5 because I'm pretty brutal, but thats an aveage of 8.17, which is pretty good.

[spectre]

Not to high jack the thread, But in the three that have been posted he's averaging round 7.5 or 8. Crash is probably the best help defender on the team besides Okafor. Most of Wallaces blocks and steals come from help defense.

Then don't...just post your own!

These are just opinions, and some things not being said will probably influence that opinion in one way or another. In regards to Crash's help defense (not like I carefully thought out any of these scores) I agree he's a great help defender, but in my opinion that sometimes takes away from what he should be doing in covering his own guy. Remember LB hit on that during the very first of the season.

But feel very free to give him a 10...I won't argue it.

Someone should add all these up and calculate the average values, after several others have posted their assessments, of course. Maybe even create a wiki article, with some neat tables and such.

I'd post my own rankings had I seen more than tidbits of their playing skill.

Great idea!

And go for it Bling...no matter how much you've seen the players no doubt you can still give a valued opinion.

[Muttley]

I like this idea, so I'm gonna try to get it back on track...


Okafor

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 5 (4, if this includes catching passes)
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 9
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 9

Total - 42/60


Diaw

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 10
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 8
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 4
Total - 42/60


Crash

Scoring talent - 8
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 8
Man defense - 8
Help defense - 9

Total 45/60


Bell

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 7
Rebounding - 5
Man defense - 9
Help defense - 6

Total 40/60


Felton

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 7
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 7
Man defense - 7
Help defense - 5

Total 39/60


Augustin

Scoring talent - 9
Passing - 7
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 5
Help defense - 5

Total 38/60


Radmanovich

Scoring talent - 9
Passing - 5
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 5

Total 36/60


Diop

Scoring talent - 5
Passing - 4
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 5
Rebounding - 8
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 7

Total 35/60


Howard

Scoring talent - 7
Passing - 6
Offensive Intangibles (screens, box outs, ball movement etc) - 6
Rebounding - 6
Man defense - 6
Help defense - 6

Total 37/60